Thanksgiving would not be complete without a slice of pie — or two — on your dessert plate. These easy Thanksgiving pie recipes provide a variety of options to choose from to satisfy all your cravings and help finish your feast the right way!
Tasty Thanksgiving Pie Recipes
What Thanksgiving celebration would be complete without a slice of pie to finish off your feast? It’s basically the mascot for the Thanksgiving dessert table! From apple pie to pumpkin pie, cranberry, and pear, there is no shortage of Thanksgiving pies to choose from to add to your Thanksgiving feast.
All of these pies will be a hit with your family and friends on Thanksgiving. No matter which one of these easy Thanksgiving pie recipes you choose to make, you won’t have any leftovers — they are all that good!
Traditional Thanksgiving Pie Recipes
Unique and Flavorful Thanksgiving Pie Recipes
1. Dutch Apple Pie
Apple pie is a staple that you must have on your Thanksgiving dessert table. The traditional dish lives up to all the hype, especially with this Dutch apple pie recipe. The apples are piled high into a super flakey pie crust and topped with a streusel topping for delicious flavor in every bite.
2. Peanut Butter Fluff Pie
Peanut butter may not seem like the most traditional pie to add to your Thanksgiving menu, but after one bite of this sweet treat, you’ll be very glad that you gave it a chance. A creamy, no-bake dessert, it’s sweet, fluffy, and super rich in the best way possible.
3. No-Bake Pumpkin Pie
You can never go wrong with the classic flavors of pumpkin pie when deciding which Thanksgiving pie recipes to make! This no-bake option provides all the sweet, spiced pumpkin flavor you know and love but is ready to eat with half the effort and doesn’t take up any room in the oven while you prepare the rest of your feast.
4. Snickerdoodle Pie
If Snickerdoodle cookies are your go-to cookie, then you’ll eat up every bite of this Snickerdoodle pie. Loaded with cinnamon and sugar and topped with a cream cheese glaze, it features everything you love about the cookies in an easy-to-make Thanksgiving pie recipe!
5. Caramel Apple Pecan Streusel Pie
Caramel, apples, and pecans are all staples when it comes to fall flavors. So why not mash them up into a pie to create the most delicious Thanksgiving dessert? Finished with a crumbly streusel topping and a drizzle of caramel sauce, it’s a well-rounded dessert recipe with flavors that blend seamlessly.
6. Pecan Pie Bars
Switch up the traditional Thanksgiving pecan pie this year, and go with pecan pie bars instead! Everything you love about the classic pie in the convenience of hand-held bars, this recipe is guaranteed to disappear fast. Do yourself a favor, and make a double batch so you don’t run out and can freeze extras to munch on well past the holiday!
7. Oreo Pie
Something tells me there were no Oreos at the first Thanksgiving, but that doesn’t mean they can’t make an appearance on your Thanksgiving table this year! Not exactly traditional, but definitely tasty, this Oreo pie is a true crowd-pleaser the whole family will love.
8. Chocolate Cream Pie Recipe
Chocolate lovers will never say no to a slice of chocolate cream pie, and this recipe is always a great option to add to your dessert menu, no matter the occasion. With just five ingredients, it comes together quickly so you can get in and out of the kitchen quickly and enjoy your holiday.
9. Salted Caramel Pumpkin Pie
Salted caramel and pumpkin may not seem like a pair that would go together. However, after one bite of this salted caramel pumpkin pie, you’ll see that the flavors are actually the perfect pairing. The caramel sweetens the pie in a subtle way that allows for the pumpkin to really shine through. This is one of the best pie recipes for Thanksgiving that will be on your menu for years to come.
10. Caramel Pear Pie
It’s time for the apples to move over, as this pie is all about the pears! Slightly crisp, they pair delightfully with the caramel sauce to create a smooth, sweet filling. Paired with a flakey, buttery crust, it’s sure to become your new favorite dessert!
11. Bourbon Sweet Potato Pie
Challenging the belief that sweet potatoes are only used for sweet potato casserole, this bourbon sweet potato pie offers cozy, comforting flavors in every delectable bite. With a smooth, spiced filling and a fluffy marshmallow creme on top, it’s sweet, savory, and perfect for the holiday.
DELICIOUS THANKSGIVING PIES
12. Shoofly Pie
If you’ve never heard of shoofly pie, get ready to fall in love. Known for its intense sweetness, this traditional pie is made with a flakey crust and a sticky molasses filling. Topped with a buttery brown sugar topping, it’s the perfect way to round out a savory meal.
13. Apple Pie
You really cannot go wrong with an apple pie on Thanksgiving. There is a reason why the pie is a staple on most Thanksgiving menus. Just don’t forget to top it with a big scoop of vanilla ice cream to enjoy it à la mode!
14. Honey Walnut Pie
Forget about the pecans, as this pie is all about the walnuts! Featuring roasted walnuts smothered with a sweet honey mixture and baked in a flakey pie crust, it’s a fun riff on a classic pecan pie that might be even tastier than the original.
15. Buttermilk Pie
If you’ve never heard of buttermilk pie, get ready for it to shoot to the top of your list. The classic southern dessert transforms tangy buttermilk into a custard filling with a sparkly, sugary topping. The rich, buttery, and tangy flavors will make your tastebuds dance!
16. Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Is there a combination better than peanut butter and chocolate? This no-bake, four-ingredient recipe proves the combination lives up to the hype! Created with a pre-made pie crust, it’s the easiest, most delicious recipe you’ll make this holiday.
17. Coconut Cream Pie
There might be snow outside on the ground this Thanksgiving, but that doesn’t mean you can’t bring the tropical flavors to your dessert table. Warm up the party inside with this coconut cream pie. It will be the unexpected hit of the dessert table!
18. Apple Cranberry Pie
Cranberries tend to get a bad reputation on Thanksgiving. They are always the side dish that goes untouched on the table. Give cranberries the love they deserve with this cranberry apple pie! Combined with apples and cinnamon spice, their tart flavor is given a makeover everyone will love.
19. Cranberry Orange Custard Pie
An underrated flavor combination, cranberries and orange create a vibrant dessert that not only tastes incredible but looks beautiful on the table. Filling your home with festive scents as it bakes, this pie recipe is unexpectedly decadent and sure to become a staple for your holiday.
20. Apple Butter Pumpkin Pie with Brown Sugar Streusel
Can’t decide on making an apple pie or a pumpkin pie this Thanksgiving? Why not make both With this apple butter pumpkin pie, you can do just that! Combining the flavors of both traditional pies making one irresistible bite, it will be the favorite on the dessert table.
21. French Silk Pie
Show off your skills in the kitchen with this rich and velvety French silk pie. Made with a classic flakey crust, a rich, silky chocolate filling, and a topping of smoothed whipped cream, it’s an unbelievably rich recipe everyone will be eager to try.
22. Cranberry Gingersnap Pie
Let Thanksgiving lead the way to the holiday season with this cranberry gingersnap pie. This pie forgets the traditional flakey pie crust and swaps in a gingersnap crust instead. If you don’t make this one on Thanksgiving, save it for Christmas and the rest of the holiday season!
23. Amish Sugar Cream Pie
This amazing pie is beautifully creamy with a nice crunch of sugar on the top. It may not be the most traditional Thanksgiving pie, but it is guaranteed to be a success. Your family will want it to be an annual addition to the Thanksgiving table.
24. Granny Smith Apple Pie
If you love tart and sweet apple pies, then this is the one for you. This pie uses all granny smith apples to give you a crisp, tart pie that is perfect for Thanksgiving.
Thanksgiving Pie Recipes FAQS
The most common Thanksgiving pie recipes include pumpkin pie, sweet potato pie, pecan pie, and apple pie.
Every recipe is different. So, you’ll want to be sure to check the specific make-ahead and storage instructions. However, in general, Thanksgiving pies can be made up to two days in advance.
Some people like to brush the inside of their pie crust with beaten egg whites or melted butter before adding the filling. This creates a barrier that prevents the liquid center from making the crust soggy.
More Delicious Thanksgiving Desserts
Quick & Easy Desserts
Caramel Apple Tart
All Recipes
Pumpkin Cookies
All Recipes
Apple Bundt Cake
All Recipes
Cake Mix Pumpkin Roll
All Recipes
Pumpkin Gooey Butter Cake
All Recipes
Looking for a recipe that had two layers. The bottom layer was chocolate, and the top layer was white chocolate with shaved chocolate on top of the white chocolate layer.
Thanks in advance for any response.