Tired of the same old pumpkin pie? Discover 10 irresistible Thanksgiving pie recipes that go beyond pumpkin, featuring unique flavors to wow your holiday guests.
Pin this recipe now to save it for later
Pin RecipeThis Thanksgiving, it’s time to shake things up at the dessert table! While pumpkin pie is a classic, there’s a whole world of irresistible pies waiting to be the star of your holiday feast. From rich and chocolatey creations to fruity and nutty favorites, these 10 Thanksgiving pies are anything but traditional—but they’re guaranteed to leave your guests asking for seconds. Let’s dig into these sweet treats!
10 Thanksgiving Pies That Aren’t Pumpkin
1. Chocolate Cream Pie
Chocolate is always a good idea, especially when it is in the form of this chocolate cream pie. The light whipped cream and rich chocolate pudding filling make the pie a great way to end the Thanksgiving meal.
2. Apple Pie
Thanksgiving wouldn’t be complete without a classic apple pie on the table. This pie uses a store-bought crust to make the pie-making process a breeze.
3. Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Impress your Thanksgiving guest with this rich and decadent chocolate peanut butter pie. The no-bake pie overloads on chocolate and peanut butter in the best way possible.
4. Lemon Cream Cheese Pie
Add a light and refreshing finish to the Thanksgiving meal with this lemon cream cheese pie. The no-bake pie is a much-needed reprieve from all the heavy Thanksgiving dishes on the table.
5. No Bake Peanut Butter Pie
You won’t miss pumpkin pie one bit when this no-bake peanut butter pie is on the table. The no-bake recipe only uses four ingredients and is super simple to make, no matter your skills in the kitchen.
6. Coconut Cream Pie
End Thanksgiving on a high note with this silky smooth coconut cream pie. The creamy pie uses instant coconut pudding to get that signature coconut flavor that flows throughout each bite.
7. Peach Pie
Add a little summertime flair to your holiday table with this peach pie. If you can’t find fresh peaches to use, frozen peaches will swap in just fine.
8. Amish Sugar Cream Pie Recipe
If you haven’t had Amish sugar cream pie, get ready to fall in love. The custard-based pie has a thick sugar topping, just like a crème brûlée. The egg-free dessert is rich, creamy, and perfect for Thanksgiving.
9. Old Fashioned Coconut Pie
I love serving an old-fashioned coconut pie on Thanksgiving. It is one of my favorite desserts that isn’t super traditional. One bite and this pie will permanently be on your Thanksgiving dessert menu for years to come.
10. Oreo Pie
If you are not the ones hosting Thanksgiving and need to bring a dessert, look no further than this Oreo pie. The pie only has six ingreidents and is always a crowd-pleaser.
Whether you’re hosting a small gathering or a feast with family and friends, these 10 Thanksgiving pies are sure to add a memorable twist to your dessert spread. With flavors this good, no one will even miss the pumpkin!
Which one will you try first? Share your favorite with us in the comments and don’t forget to pin or save this post to your Pinterest holiday recipe board!
