This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.
Looking for the best cottage cheese substitutes? Whether you need a quick substitute for cottage cheese, a dairy-free option, or simply don’t love the curdy texture, there are plenty of smart ways to replace cottage cheese without sacrificing flavor, texture, or nutrition.
We love cottage cheese in these Bacon & Gruyere Sous Vide Egg Bites and Orange Fluff Salad, but if you don’t have it on hand? Read on!
Why you might need these cottage cheese substitutes!
Cottage cheese is popular in both sweet and savory recipes thanks to its mild flavor, high protein content, and creamy-yet-textured consistency. It’s commonly used in everything from dips and lasagna to cheesecakes, breakfast bowls, and healthy snacks.
While cottage cheese is versatile, it’s not for everyone.
- Texture issues: Some people dislike the curds.
- Dietary needs: Cottage cheese isn’t suitable for dairy-free or vegan diets.
- Flavor preferences: Even mild foods aren’t universally loved.
- Out of stock: Sometimes you just need a replacement for cottage cheese in a pinch—just like when you’re hunting for oil substitutes for cake mix mid-recipe.
The good news? There’s a cottage cheese substitute for nearly every situation.
This guide breaks down the best cottage cheese replacements based on how you plan to use them, including baking, cooking, spreading, blending, or boosting protein.
Table of Contents
- Why you might need these cottage cheese substitutes!
- Quick Guide: Choosing the Best Substitute for Cottage Cheese
- Cheesy Cottage Cheese Substitutes
- Non-Cheese Dairy Substitutes
- Quick Tip
- Vegan & Dairy-Free Cottage Cheese Alternatives
- Animal-Based Protein Substitutes
- Frequently Asked Questions
- More Helpful Substitutes
Quick Guide: Choosing the Best Substitute for Cottage Cheese
Here’s a quick guide to cottage cheese substitutes before we dig into the finer details!
- For dairy-free/vegan: Tofu, hummus, chickpea puree
- For lasagna & baked pasta: Ricotta, blended cottage cheese alternatives, Greek yogurt (strained)
- For dips & spreads: Cream cheese, Greek yogurt, goat cheese, tofu
- For baking & desserts: Ricotta, mascarpone, cream cheese
- For protein replacement: Greek yogurt, tofu, egg whites, lean meats
Cheesy Cottage Cheese Substitutes
1. Ricotta Cheese
Ricotta is one of the best cottage cheese substitutes thanks to its similar mild flavor and creamy texture.
- Best for: Lasagna, baked pasta, stuffed shells, desserts (try it in stuffed lasagna spaghetti squash and million dollar spaghetti)
- How to substitute: 1:1 replacement
- Tip: For a closer match, use whole-milk ricotta or blend it briefly
2. Feta Cheese
Feta has a crumbly texture similar to cottage cheese but a much saltier, tangier flavor.
- Best for: Savory dishes, salads, Mediterranean recipes
- How to substitute: Start with ½ the amount and reduce added salt
3. Goat Cheese
Soft goat cheese offers creaminess with a noticeable tang.
- Best for: Savory bakes, dips, toast toppings
- How to substitute: Start with half, then adjust to taste
4. Fromage Blanc
A lesser-known but excellent cottage cheese alternative, fromage blanc is creamy and lightly tangy.
- Best for: Sweet or savory recipes
- How to substitute: 1:1 replacement
5. Mascarpone
Mascarpone is richer and sweeter than cottage cheese.
- Best for: Desserts, cheesecakes, creamy fillings
- How to substitute: 1:1, plus a squeeze of lemon juice for tang
6. Cream Cheese
Cream cheese lacks curds but works beautifully when smoothness matters.
- Best for: Cheesecake, dips, frostings
- How to substitute: 1:1 replacement
7. Kefir
Kefir is thinner and more pourable but still tangy and protein-rich.
- Best for: Dips, sauces, blended recipes
- How to substitute: 1:1, reduce other liquids if needed
8. Faisselle Cheese
A close European cousin to cottage cheese.
- Best for: Nearly any recipe
- How to substitute: 1:1 replacement
Non-Cheese Dairy Substitutes
9. Greek Yogurt
Greek yogurt is one of the most popular ways to replace cottage cheese, especially for health-focused recipes.
- Best for: Dips, bowls, baking
- How to substitute: 1:1 (strain excess liquid first)
10. Whipped Heavy Cream
Light and airy, whipped cream works best in desserts.
- Best for: Sweet recipes
- How to substitute: 1:1, expect lighter texture
11. Sour Cream
Tangy and smooth, sour cream works well as a replacement for cottage cheese in savory applications.
- Best for: Dips, spreads, casseroles
- How to substitute: 1:1 replacement
Quick Tip
If you’re concerned about the ratio of substitution when using an alternative to cottage cheese, start with a smaller amount and gradually increase if needed. This works with spreads and dips but may be trickier for baking. If you’re unsure, try testing a recipe ahead of time, and opt for a cottage cheese substitute you feel confident about using.
Vegan & Dairy-Free Cottage Cheese Alternatives
12. Tofu
Blended tofu mimics cottage cheese surprisingly well.
- Best for: Savory dishes, pasta, spreads
- How to substitute: 1:1 (blend for smoothness)
13. Hummus
Use only plain hummus to avoid overpowering flavors.
- Best for: Savory dips
- How to substitute: 1:1 in small amounts
14. Chickpea Puree
A simple homemade option when you’re out of alternatives.
- Best for: Savory recipes
- How to substitute: Blend until smooth; adjust seasoning
15. Bean Puree (Red or White)
Creamy but stronger in flavor.
- Best for: Savory dishes only
- How to substitute: Start small and increase gradually
16. Almond Milk
Works only when cottage cheese is used as a liquid component.
- Best for: Baking
- How to substitute: 1:1, reduce other liquids
Animal-Based Protein Substitutes
17. Egg White
A great lactose-free breakfast alternative.
- Best for: Toast, breakfast bowls
- How to substitute: 1:1 cooked egg whites
20. Fish, Poultry, & Lean Meat
If protein is your goal, not texture, these are solid replacements.
- Best for: High-protein meals
- How to substitute: Use equivalent protein portions
Frequently Asked Questions
Cottage cheese is a fresh cheese that is made by combining cheese with an acid culture. To make it, an acid or acid-producing culture is added to milk. This starts the process of separating the liquid whey from the milk solids, also known as curds and whey. Then, the curds are washed and combined with cream and salt.
Ricotta cheese is the best overall cottage cheese substitute because it has a similar mild flavor, creamy texture, and works in both sweet and savory recipes.
Yes! Greek yogurt is an excellent replacement for cottage cheese in dips, spreads, and baking. Use a 1:1 ratio and strain excess liquid first.
Blended tofu is the best dairy-free cottage cheese alternative. It’s high in protein, mild in flavor, and works well in savory recipes.
Ricotta, mascarpone, cream cheese, or Greek yogurt are the best substitutes for cottage cheese in baking and desserts.
💌 Love easy recipes? Join my newsletter and get my Top 10 Reader-Favorite Recipes eBook FREE! Sign up here.
More Helpful Substitutes
Kitchen Tips
10 Best Sour Cream Substitutes
All Recipes
Pumpkin Purée Substitutes
Kitchen Tips
